Thursday, June 13, 2013

PPP -- profits before people

THE PRIVATIZATION mantra is being incessantly hummed by the Aquino III administration. Privatization is being promoted to the public as the solution to deteriorated, broken-down and inadequate public utilities and social services. The argument is not new: government just doesn’t have the resources to provide for these public goods. Coupled with this line is the conventional wisdom that governments are prone to mismanagement and corruption so much so that only private capital investment and management could solve the problem.

Thus the so-called public-private partnership or PPP has become the centerpiece economic program of Mr. Aquino. He, however, is merely taking a leaf from his mother, former President Corazon Aquino, who implemented the first build-operate-transfer (BOT) scheme for the power sector in the country in 1987 when the Philippine economy was subject to the conditionalities of the structural adjustment programs laid down by the International Monetary Fund. PPP projects are basically BOTs with a new, fancier title.

The privatization of the Metropolitan Waterworks and Sewerage Service (MWSS) in 1997 is considered to be the country’s showcase for such schemes. It was the largest water privatization project in the world at the time costing close to $8 billion. The Ramos government touted the project as the answer to the water crisis in Metro Manila and adjoining areas promising lower rates, better quality water, universal coverage and a more efficient use of scarce water resources. Filipino firms owned by the Ayalas and Lopezes (and later, the Consunjis and MV Pangilinan group of companies when the Lopezes divested) partnered with foreign investors from the US, France, UK, the Netherlands, Japan and China/Hong Kong to successfully bid for these contracts.

The move was immediately met with opposition, spearheaded by the MWSS Employees’ Union who unjustly stood to be displaced by privatization, supported by consumers who anticipated higher water rates once this vital public service is subjected to the bottom line of big business -- profit.

In two years’ time however, water rates began their steady and steep climb, especially so with rate rebasing that took place every five years. By the 1st quarter of 2013, water rates were 7-12 times higher than pre-privatization rates. This year the rate increase is already under negotiation between MWSS, the government regulatory body, and the two concessionaires: Manila Water is asking for an increase of the basic charge by ₱5.38 per cubic meter (m3); Maynilad, by ₱10.30. Together with other charges such as 12% VAT, environment charge and foreign currency differential adjustment, this adds up to a hefty increase of ₱7.81/m3 for Manila Water and ₱13.71/m3 for Maynilad.

What does this mean for consumers? According to the national democratic alliance, BAYAN, one way to look at it is to compute the increase in monthly water bills for a low monthly consumption of 10 m3 and a "high" of 30 m3. This rate hike will range from ₱78.10 to ₱234.30 for Manila Water and ₱137.10 to ₱411.30 for Maynilad per month. But the real impact is revealed by comparing such increases with family incomes, especially of the more economically disadvantaged.

To illustrate, assuming the daily minimum wage in the National Capital Region (NCR)is at ₱419-456, the water bill to be charged by Maynilad for 10 m3 monthly consumption would be 3-4% of an ordinary worker’s earnings while it would be 2-3 % for Manila Water. At 30 m3 consumption, the figures are 10-11% for the former, 7-8% for the latter.

Such calculations were confirmed to even be underestimated in a study conducted by the policy research outfit IBON in four urban poor communities in NCR. Water connections cost anywhere between ₱1,300 and ₱10,000 and effective water rates are ₱20-75/m3 (for sub-metered connections) and ₱63-₱333/m3 (for water bought in containers). The community is populated by kasambahay or household workers, pedicab/tricycle/jeepney drivers, construction workers, vendors, security guards and janitors with daily earnings of ₱100-400 or ₱3,000-12,000 monthly. The portion of their earnings that goes to paying for water is anywhere between 7-22% (at an income ₱100-150/day) and 3-15% (income ₱300-350/day).

Quite starkly, the wealthy households in Ayala Heights, Quezon City pay roughly the same rates as those in the slum area nearby who are fortunately connected to the water main. Those poorer households that make do with sub-meters pay several pesos more per cubic meter consumption while those who pay for water by the balde containers pay three to five times more. Thus the poor have to pay for their water at astoundingly higher rates than the rich do because the water reaches them through middle men.

Which brings us to ask what ever happened to the private concessionaires’ claims that they had achieved close to a hundred percent coverage of their franchise areas? According to IBON, the most recent representative survey data for access to safe water in the entire country including NCR is from the 2008 Annual Poverty Indicators Survey which makes it difficult to cross check the water concessionaires’ claims. (It is also an unflattering indication of how assiduous is the government in compiling data relevant and necessary to its regulatory function.)

Nonetheless, the official data shows that upon privatization (1997), the percentage of families without access to safe water was 12.2%. Post privatization (2008), it stood at 8.4%. On the other hand, the rising absolute numbers of households without access to safe water, from 201,117 to 204,036, is cause for alarm.

BAYAN says that not all households have individual connections; in urban poor communities, most rely on bulk meter connections that result in higher rates. In many areas water pressure is low such that water flows only at specified, and even ungodly, hours. In fact the physical infrastructure for water supply in many areas still appear to be antiquated resulting to the bursting of water mains that caused flash floods in thoroughfares and residential areas such as those at EDSA in 2010, Las PiƱas in 2012 and Mandaluyong in 2013. It would be useful for a study to be made comparing the incidence of water-borne diseases in NCR pre- and post-privatization.

Most useful data culled by IBON is the robust profits garnered by Maynilad and Manila Water from 2008-2011, a 44% average annual increase for Maynilad and 15% for Manila Water. In fact the two water companies have been able to expand: Manila Water owns Boracay Island Water, Clark Water, Laguna Water and Kehn Dong Water Supply at Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam; Ayala & Pangilinan, for their part, have cornered the Cebu Bulk Water project.

To check whether the water firms’ profits are indeed quite healthy, perhaps even unconscionable from the point of view that the commodity they are profiting from is one so vital to life, health and wellbeing, IBON estimated their respective rates of return on equity (ROE) or how much the company is earning from funds invested by its stockholders: Maynilad’s is 48%; Manila Water, 19%. These figures are reportedly higher than those of companies in the telecommunications, power and mining industries.

At the end of the day, this only underscores that with privatization, water firms controlled by the biggest names in the local and foreign business community are raking in their profits and government gets its similarly gargantuan tax revenue, while the poorest and middle-income households are bled dry.

With the privatization of water services considered to be the model for the PPP program of the Aquino regime, the common tao is in for a lot more hardship and misery, all for the glory of private profit. Looming just around the corner is the privatization of government hospitals, starting with the National Orthopedic Hospital.

It is as if we are not suffering enough from the unending increases in electric power rates and oil and gasoline prices, the Aquino regime would want us to believe that the best this government can offer is more of the same.


source:  Businessworld's Streetwise by Carol Araullo

Friday, June 7, 2013

PPP to check natgas pipeline viability

CLARK FREEPORT ZONE—The probability of constructing a natural gas pipeline from Batangas to Manila is set to be determined this year, Zenaida Monsada, director of the Oil Industry Management Bureau of the Department of Energy (DOE), said on Thursday.

Monsada said the Philippine National Oil Co. (PNOC) has tapped the Public-Private Partnership (PPP) Center to conduct a feasibility study for the proposed Batangas-Manila (Batman 1) natural gas pipeline.

The DOE official said the study is targeted for completion within the year or by the first quarter of next year.

“The study will also include the terms of reference for the bidding, the engineering, procurement, and construction of the project,” Monsada said.

The 105-kilometer Batman 1 natural gas pipeline is estimated to cost between $100 million to $150 million and is eyed for completion between 2015 and 2017, if proven feasible.

The project, which will be undertaken by the state-owned PNOC, is seen to jumpstart the natural gas industry in the country.

The idea is to tap the PPP Center’s pool of international consultants who can “provide an international perspective” for the project, the energy official said.

PPP Center Executive Director Cosette Canilao said the PPP Center will tap funds from the agency’s Project Development and Monitoring Facility (PDMF).

The fund is intended to be used for the preparation of pre-feasibility, feasibility studies, and tender documents for PPP projects, and assistance in the bidding process.

“PNOC has tapped the PDMF to undertake study and structuring of the Batman project, for a possible PPP,” Canilao said.

The PPP Center was tasked under the Executive Order No. 8 series of 2010 to facilitate the coordination and monitoring of the PPP programs and projects in the country.

source:  Malaya

Thursday, June 6, 2013

Only one qualifies for MRT-3 projects

Only one proponent has qualified to bid for two key Metro Rail Transit (MRT3) projects -- the P712-million Temporary Maintenance Provider and the P25-million supply and delivery magnetic tickets.

According to the Department of Transportation and Communications (DOTC) Bids and Awards Committee (BAC), only Autre Porte Technique (APT) Global, Inc. qualified for the next stages of the bidding process for MRT 3 temporary maintenance provider project, after the other two bidder were disqualified.

“APT Global submitted a bid in the amount of around P685 million. Financial proposals of the two other interested groups were no longer opened after they were found to be ineligible,” said DOTC spokesperson Miguel Sagcal.

The disqualified groups were Asiaphil Manufacturing Industries, Inc. in joint venture with Korea Railroad, which did not comply with sealing and marking requirements of Republic Act No. 9184 (the Procurement Law); and Commbuilders and Technology Philippines Corporation, which failed to submit a certificate of satisfactory performance.

“Unfortunately, it once more came down to two groups’ failure to comply with the bid requirements. Time and again, we have said that the DOTC-BAC can do nothing but to follow the Procurement Law, which prohibits it from exercising discretion,” Sagcal added.

source:  Malaya

SMC pays P11B for PPP project

San Miguel Corp. (SMC) said on Wednesday it has paid the P11 billion it committed itself to when it won the bidding for the right to build the Ninoy Aquino International Airport (NAIA) Expressway.

Through its subsidiary Optimal Infrastructure, SMC topped the bidding for the second Public-Private Partnership project of the government after promising to pay P11 billion upfront to construct the expressway.
Ramon Ang, SMC president, said it now awaits the government to comply with its commitment to provide the road right of way as well as project design, after which the company will start construction.

“Immediately after they’ve provided the design and ROA, we will construct it quickly,” said Ang on the sidelines of San Miguel unit San Miguel Properties Inc.’s stockholders meeting.

The seven kilometer, four-lane expressway will connect NAIA to Pagcor City in Paranaque City, while linking two existing expressways, Skyway and the Manila-Cavite Toll Expressway.

It will have entry and exit ramps at Roxas Boulevard, Macapagal Boulevard, and Pagcor City.

Ang also said his group expects the completion of a share sale by unit Philippine Airlines within the month in order to comply with the Philippine Stock Exchange’s 10 percent minimum public float.

Ang, without providing details, said the sale will be facilitated by PNB Capital.

Meanwhile Presidential Spokesman Edwin Lacierda said yesterday that traffic rerouting schemes would be enforced to ease congestion and minimize inconvenience to motorists during construction.

He said they hope to complete the construction of the expressway in time for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in 2015. with Jocelyn Montemayor

source:  Malaya

Friday, May 31, 2013

It’s TriNoMa over SM as common station

The Department of Transportation and Communication (DOTC) has chosen to locate near TriNoma (the Ayala-owned Triangle North of Manila mall) the common station it plans to build that will link the three train lines in Metro Manila.

Joseph Emilio Abaya, transport secretary said the government will return to SM Prime Holdings Inc. the  P200 million it paid to Light Rail Transit Authority (LRTA) for the “naming rights” of the common station on the premise that it would be located near SM North, Abaya said. It is a “naming rights” not “ location rights” Abaya said.

The government has allotted over P1.6 billion for the common station that will connect the existing Metro Rail Transit Line 3 (MRT 3), the Light Rail Transit Line 1, and the proposed MRT 7 project.

LRT 1 runs from Baclaran to Roosevelt in Quezon City, while the MRT 3 runs from North Avenue in Quezon City to Taft Avenue in Pasay City.

The planned MRT 7 will begin at Tala, Caloocan City, passing through Lagro and Fairview, Novaliches, Batasan, Diliman, Philcoa, before ending at Edsa corner North Avenue. The railway will serve an estimated two million commuters in the northern parts of Quezon and Caloocan cities.

Joseph Emilio Abaya, transport secretary, told reporters yesterday that DOTC is now looking at two options to complete the project faster: either the government will do it or tack it into the LRT 1 extension project.
Abaya said it will be cheaper to build a common station near TriNoma than at the SM North Edsa mall where LRT 1 extension ends.

SM Prime Holdings Inc. has paid P200 million to Light Rail Transit Authority (LRTA) for the “naming rights” of the common station on the premise that it would be located near SM North, Abaya said.

Another major priority for the DOTC is the development of metro rail lines, including the LRT Line 1 South Extension to Cavite, and the Automatic Fare Collection System (AFCS). Both are being implemented under the Public Private Partnership program of the government.

The Line 1 Cavite Extension is actually the biggest project, with a total cost of P60 billion.

Half of that will be subsidized by the government with a supply of rail cars to be procured from Japan through Official Development Assistance (ODA).

The other half will be the PPP component, wherein a winning bidder will take over operation and management of the existing line while it builds the 12-kilometer extension to the southern province of Cavite.
“We expect this to benefit a lot of people, especially those whose source of livelihood is here in Manila but are forced to take a very long commute everyday. Bidding for the project is ongoing, and we have four proponents who will be submitting their proposals within the next month or so,” Abaya said.

The AFCS on the other hand seeks to replicate the efficient ticketing system of rail lines abroad, wherein riders use a contactless smart card to access the train stations.

“We hope that once this P1.72 billion project is in place, we can minimize the queuing in our train stations and increase passenger convenience,” Abaya said .

Another DOTC project is the putting up of an extension for LRT 2 to Masinag, Antipolo, which Abaya said is intended to give residents of eastern sectors of Metro Manila “a more accessible route in the metropolis.”

source:  Malaya

Tuesday, May 7, 2013

PPP concerns raised

A STRING of credit rating upgrades will attract more investments to the Philippines but the government’s much-touted public private partnership (PPP) program may not be able to keep up, consultancy GlobalSource Partners yesterday said.

With Standard & Poor’s following Fitch Ratings in raising the Philippines to investment grade, there will be a gradual pickup in investments, especially in public works, GlobalSource said.

"Our best-case scenario would see inflows channeled into productive investments in infrastructure and tradeable goods that create local jobs and sustain economic growth over the long term."

"Conversely, in the worst case, the economy would be ill-prepared to absorb the inflows which end up distorting investment decisions and creating asset bubbles that raise the economy’s vulnerability to external shocks...".

S&P raised the Philippines’ credit rating to BBB- last week, following an identical move by Fitch in March. Both moves took the country to investment grade -- a category where an economy is deemed to have "adequate capacity" to meet financial commitments.

With many investors required to tap only investment grade entities, the upgrades are expected to spark renewed interest in the Philippines and its companies.

However, GlobalSource said the country may have limited opportunities to offer with the Aquino administration’s centerpiece infrastructure development program continually hit by delays.

"Despite the flurry of activities, many well-informed observers continue to doubt that government can in fact proceed to bid out anytime soon some of the bigger projects..." it noted.

For deals that can be bid out, it added, questions remain on whether these can be completed by 2016 and whether the activity generated will contribute to economic growth.

The government has had to appease investors after "seemingly unending postponements of critical milestones" in the PPP program, which was launched with much fanfare in 2010.

Only two projects have been awarded so far: the P1.96-billion Daang Hari-South Luzon Expressway Link to Ayala Corp. and the P16.42-billion PPP School Infrastructure Project Phase One to the Citicore Holdings Investment, Inc.-Megawide Construction Corp., Inc. and BF Corp.-Riverbanks Development Corp. consortiums.

The P15.86-billion Ninoy Aquino International Airport (NAIA) Expressway Project, meanwhile, will formally awarded to Optimal Infrastructure Development, Inc., a unit of San Miguel Corp., this month.

"In the case of the NAIA Expressway, apart from the usual bottlenecks common in toll road projects (e.g., timely delivery of right of way) that can lead to delays, the perplexing bid results have doused some of our pre-bid enthusiasm for a likely PPP takeoff," GlobalSource noted.

San Miguel offered an upfront P11 billion on top of the project cost, almost double a P6-billion interest-free loan offered by the government. It was also well above the P305 million proposed by Manila North Tollways Corp.

"The numbers we have seen suggest that the project will be difficult to fund on a project finance basis and has analysts guessing what game plan San Miguel has in mind..." it said.


source:  Businessworld

A new meaning for PPPs? (1)

THE SIMPLEST IDEAS are sometimes the most effective. Recently, the MMDA moved the Fort-bound U-turn under the EDSA-Buendia flyover one slot forward, resulting in smoother traffic transitions on the EDSA-Guadalupe-bound lane.

Meantime, the march of LEDs continues as TMC, the operator of the NLEx, has converted the lighting masts from the Balintawak to Balagtas segment to all LED, enhancing the highway’s all-weather safety. With road illumination now on par with China and Europe’s latest expressways, areas that still do not have road illumination, like the Balagtas to Sta. Rita segment where there is also no high concrete median barrier, should at least have median anti-glare barriers. For that matter, anti-glare barriers were once promised for the MATES-managed SLEx from Alabang to Sto. Tomas.

Even as the administration’s focus is sidelined by the elections, many line departments are continuing with the task of trying to fulfill the Noynoy Aquino’s dream of finishing his term as the PPP president. But despite the glowing reports on foreign investment and the hyper-optimism of local businessmen, the 2013 IMF country report states that our growth is still “non-inclusive”; i.e. in layman’s terms, the growth doesn’t translate to the masses, which has been lucidly explained by UP professor Benjamin Diokno. This is backstopped by the 2013 World Economic Forum’s Global Competitiveness Report where our country is at the bottom rung in terms of power, land, sea and air transportation. Could this be because of the snail’s pace of infrastructure since 2010?

Catching up on infrastructure in the busy metro, improvement of drainage, footbridges and lane alignments on the Quezon City segment of C-5 -- the only workable north-south alternative to EDSA -- are also in preparation when north-south traffic increases when Tandang Sora at Commonwealth is fully widened. The timing could only be prescient just as EDSA is to receive an end-to-end full asphalt overlay, plus the impending construction of the roller coaster skyway from Malibay to Roxas Boulevard on EDSA.

The government has all but awarded the NAIA Skyway Stage 2 to Entertainment City by the Bay PPP to San Miguel’s Optimal Infrastructure.

This is the second highway awarded under the program in the three years of the Aquino administration. Most of the bidding for the LRT and MRT related upgrades, meanwhile, have been postponed several times over.

Up north, the BCDA continues paying interest for the loan that built the SCTEx as the Palace hasn’t okayed the turnover of the SCTEx to Metro Pacific Tollways, which will take over debt servicing and integrate SCTEx operations and expenses as it runs the NLEx. Metro Pacific Tollways has submitted a 4th revised offer -- the contract, mind, was approved in 2009.


source:  Businessworld Column of Not So Fast by Tito F. Hermoso