Tuesday, December 10, 2013

DoTC to open bids for MCIA tomorrow

THE DEPARTMENT of Transportation and Communications (DoTC) announced yesterday that it will open the financial proposals for the first airport public-private partnership (PPP) project on Thursday.

The agency is scheduled to complete the technical evaluation stage for the P17.5-billion Mactan-Cebu International Airport (MCIA) Project today.

The DoTC bids and awards committee will then determine how many of the seven bidders will be eligible for the financial evaluation phase.

It has set a 15-day deadline for the completion of the technical checks from the submission of the bids on Nov. 28. Awarding of the project is set in mid-January.

DoTC Spokesman Michael Arthur C. Sagcal said in a statement that the agency is expediting the tendering process of the project, as the department is poised to offer two new PPP deals this month and next year.

"We are expediting work on our PPPs, especially now that we are re-bidding the LRT (Light Rail Transit) Line 1 Cavite Extension project and preparing to bid out the Integrated Transport System (ITS) project later this month," Mr. Sagcal said.

These seven parties submitted their financial and technical proposals for the airport deal to the DoTC yesterday:

• Metro Pacific - JG Summit consortium;

• AAA Airport Partners of the Ayala and Aboitiz groups;

• Filinvest-CAI consortium;

• San Miguel - Incheon Airport consortium;

• First Philippine Airports led by First Philippine Holdings;

• Premier Airport Group led by SM Investments Corp.; and

• the GMR Infrastructure and Megawide consortium.

Meanwhile, new players have indicated interest in bidding for the LRT-1 extension project, with local construction firm Megawide Corp. and Spanish rail transport operator Globalvia Infraestructuras, S.A. purchasing bid documents.

Bidding for the project is scheduled for April 28 next year.

DMCI Holdings, Inc. and San Miguel Corp., both of which pre-qualified to bid during the initial tender, have obtained bid documents as well.

The DoTC also plans to start the bidding process for the ITS terminals on Coastal Road in southern Metro Manila within the month. This project is to provide commuters with modern and efficient transport hubs where they can conveniently transfer to in-city buses, the LRT-1 system, or other forms of urban transport. -- L.C.S. Marasigan

 
source:  Businessworld

Monday, December 9, 2013

Cutting corners in the tax assessment process

WITH Manny Pacquiao’s tax evasion case with the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) still a sizzling topic, the tax office issued a new revenue regulation that is making waves among taxpayers, tax practitioners and revenue officers with regard to the due process requirements in issuing deficiency tax assessments.

The rules governing the issuance of deficiency tax assessments are long established under Section 228 of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997 (Tax Code) and its implementing regulation, RR No. 12-99. Under the old rules, after the examination of a taxpayer’s books of accounts and other records pursuant to a Letter of Authority or a Letter Notice, the BIR officer who performed the audit shall notify the taxpayer of the discrepancy or discrepancies in the latter’s tax payments, by issuing a Notice of Informal Conference. The taxpayer is then given 15 days to present his side of the case.

In case the taxpayer fails to timely respond to the Notice of Informal Conference, the revenue officer may endorse his findings for the issuance of a Preliminary Assessment Notice (PAN) or a Formal Letter of Demand (FLD)/Final Assessment Notice (FAN), whenever the case falls under the situations enumerated in the Tax Code when a PAN is no longer required. Again, once a PAN is issued, the taxpayer has 15 days to refute the findings of the revenue officer.

If the issues are not resolved at the PAN stage, the BIR may issue the FLD/FAN calling for the payment of the deficiency taxes. The taxpayer is given 30 days from receipt of the FLD/FAN to submit a written protest against the assessments, and 60 days from the filing of the written protest to submit all relevant supporting documents. The taxpayer’s failure to protest the FLD/FAN or submit all relevant supporting documents within the prescribed period makes the tax assessments final, executory and demandable.

If the Commissioner of Internal Revenue or his duly authorized representative denies the protest, or fails to act on the protest, the taxpayer may elevate the decision of the Commissioner to the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) within 30 days from receipt of the denial or lapse of the 180-day period for the Commissioner to decide. The taxpayer’s failure to timely appeal the adverse decision or the inaction of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue to the CTA makes the assessments final, executory and demandable.

Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 18-2013, dated Nov. 28, 2013, changed the pace of the tax assessment and collection process by introducing the following amendments:

1. Omission of the issuance of the Notice of Informal Conference;

2. Issuance of the FLD/FAN within 15 days from receipt of the PAN, in case of default by the taxpayer, or within 15 days from filing of the reply to the PAN, in case of disagreement with the tax findings in the PAN;

3. Requirement on the part of the taxpayer to state the nature of protest to the FLD/FAN, whether for request for reconsideration and request for reinvestigation, and prescribing the legal effects of each mode;

4. Institution of the administrative appeal with the Commissioner of Internal Revenue through request for reconsideration, in which the taxpayer is barred from presenting newly discovered or additional evidence to support his case;

5. Inclusion of an exclusivity rule in case of inaction of the Commissioner on the protested assessment, i.e., the remedy of filing a petition for review with the Court of Tax Appeals bars the remedy of waiting for the final decision of the Commissioner or his duly authorized representative, which decision is subject to appeal to the CTA;

6. Institution of personal service and substituted service as modes of serving the PAN/FLD/FAN and the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment (FDDA) in addition to service by registered mail.

The most notable amendment introduced by RR 18-2013 is the removal of the Notice of Informal Conference. The Notice of Informal Conference is not a requirement under the Tax Code; nevertheless, it was institutionalized under RR 12-99 as part of procedural due process. In scrapping this requirement, the BIR aims to achieve an assessment and collection process which, in numerous cases decided by the courts, is defeated by the defense of prescription under the statute of limitations of the Tax Code.

The BIR seems to be keen on formalizing the tax assessment after the investigation reaches the PAN stage. It is interesting to note that the BIR only has 15 days to resolve the issues in the PAN stage and issue the FLD/FAN. A real evaluation of the documents and arguments of the documents submitted by the taxpayer takes time and needs more than 15 days. Understanding the documents, tax reconciliations and legal defenses is impossible to do within a short period of 15 days primarily because of the huge numbers of tax investigations assigned to revenue officers. The only way to prevent the issuance of the FLD/FAN is to settle the tax assessments in the PAN, which would make one wonder why replying to the PAN is one of a taxpayer’s remedies in the first place.

The shortened period does not give the taxpayers enough time to prepare his documents and arguments. More importantly, it does not allow the BIR officers enough time to consider and study the documents and arguments presented to them.

It would seem that the shortened period, though aimed at expediting the process, however makes the PAN stage inutile.

There are other interesting provisions in RR No. 18-2013 which, in my opinion, should have been the topic of an open forum between the BIR and taxpayers, or now that it is issued, be the subject to a clarificatory issuance by the BIR. This "game changer" will take effect on Dec. 15, 2013, and given its important amendments, it pays to have a proper understanding of procedural due process as part of a taxpayer’s rights and remedies under the law.

The author is a tax manager at Punongbayan & Araullo, the Philippine member firm of Grant Thornton International Ltd.

 
source:   Businessworld

Saturday, December 7, 2013

P1.7-B single ticketing system for MRT, LRT: 3 groups qualify for DOTC project











MANILA, Philippines - The Department of Transportation and Communications (DOTC) said three of the five prequalified groups that submitted bids for the P1.7-billion single ticketing system project for the Metro Rail Transit (MRT) and the Light Rail Transit (LRT) passed the agency’s technical evaluation.

DOTC spokesperson Michael Arthur Sagcal said the AF consortium led by conglomerate Ayala Corp. and infrastructure giant Metro Pacific Investments Corp. (MPIC) of businessman Manuel V. Pangilinan; Comworks-Berjaya consortium; and the SM consortium of retail magnate Henry Sy Sr. passed the evaluation conducted by the agency’s Bids and Awards Committee (BAC).

“We will carefully review the financial proposals of the three remaining groups only.  At the end of the day, we must make sure that both government and the public will get the most advantageous terms possible,” Sagcal stressed.

After opening the financial proposals on Monday, he said the agency would conduct a financial evaluation of each opened submission in accordance with the Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT) Law.

“We have been speeding up the process.  At the rate we are going, we should be able to award the contract by January,” he added.

The two groups that failed to hurdle the agency’s technical evaluation were the E-Trans Solutions Joint Venture Inc. and Megawide-Suyen-Eurolink consortium due to substantial deficiencies regarding their ability to implement the project.

According to the BAC, E-Trans Solutions’, technical proposal did not describe the required conditions for use of the project, which would protect the card user’s data privacy. It was also found to be incomplete, unclear, and did not show compliance with the project’s scheme provider principles. Moreover, its business plan did not follow the projection computations contained in the draft concession agreement.

As for Megawide-Suyen-Eurolink, its business plan was found to be incomplete and inconsistent and did not contain the required project internal rate of return, making it impossible to evaluate the project’s feasibility.
In addition, the payment and revenue numbers it indicated in one section of the business plan contradicted the very same items contained in another section. It also pegged its post-tax equity return at -2.64 percent, which indicates that the proposal may not be self-sustaining.

All five groups submitted technical bids and financial bids for the P1.72 billion Automatic Fare Collection System (AFCS) project last Nov. 18.

The winning consortium has the option to expand the contactless card system to other businesses in and out of the transportation sector such as in retail transactions.

The MRT-LRT single ticket is envisioned to be like Hong Kong’s Octopus Card, which serves as a debit card, aside from being a stored-value train ticket. The single ticket could also be used for other modes of transportation such as buses, paying toll, electronic banking, and even shopping.

The AFCS project would bring important benefits to the more than one million daily passengers using the light rail lines, ensuring seamless interconnection for travelers and removing the current inconvenience of the need to buy separate tickets for separate lines.

It would allow the operating authorities to develop a service offering that better suit the needs of the passengers through a system similar to Hong Kong, London, the Netherlands and other countries.
It would replace the current magnetic-based ticketing system that is very much at the end of its usability and could also serve as an electronic micropayment solution in convenience stores, or as identifier for loyalty schemes, facility access and location based services as well as other transport modes including buses and taxi cabs.

The riding public has long urged government to implement a common ticketing system for the LRT Lines 1 and 2 and the MRT 3 as the different ticketing schemes employed in the three mass transport systems have been blamed for the long lines of passengers buying tickets at the train stations.

The MRT line that runs from Baclaran in Pasay City to North Ave. in Quezon City services around 600,000 passengers per day, way above its capacity of 350,000.

On the other hand, LRT Line 1, which runs from Baclaran in Pasay City to Roosevelt in Quezon City, serves at least 500,000 passengers daily while the LRT Line 2, which operates from Recto in Manila to Santolan in Pasig City, caters to 350,000.

source:  Philippine Star

Thursday, December 5, 2013

Oil exploration schedule extended

THE JOINT VENTURE of Australian firm Nido Petroleum Ltd. and PNOC-Exploration Corp. (PNOC-EC) will proceed next year with drilling of an exploration well in Service Contract (SC) 63 located in waters southwest of Palawan.

This came after the Energy department approved the joint venture’s request to extend the SC 63 work program until 2014, according to Nido’s report to the Australian Securities Exchange.

Nido said: “the Department of Energy has formally confirmed its approval of the extension of the current sub-phase.” The joint venture had sought a 12-month extension of the current sub-phase which lapsed last month. The extension will allow the joint venture to drill in the area until Nov. 23 next year.

Nido, as the operator, said it is “continuing to progress preparation [sic] for the drilling campaign in relation to the Baragatan prospect and is currently finalizing negotiations with a rig contractor on behalf of the SC 63 joint venture.”

“Nido expects to drill the Baragatan prospect in the first half of the 2014,” the report read.

Last month, Nido reported it had already signed a letter of intent with a preferred rig contractor to drill the exploratory well and that a binding agreement could be signed before yearend.

The joint venture has already secured various permits to drill the well. Other equipment like the wellhead and casing are being stored in Nido’s operations base in Batangas, according to the firm.

Nido last May said the joint venture will spend $22-25 million to drill the exploration well.

SC 63 was awarded to the joint venture in November 2006. The petroleum block covers an area of 1,067,000 hectares. Nido and PNOC-EC each hold 50% interest.

Besides SC 63, Nido also holds 22.88% interest in SC 14 or the Galoc oil field located in waters northwest of Palawan. It also owns stake in other exploration areas in the Philippines, which are SC 54A (42.40%); SC 54B (60%); SC 58 (50%); and SC 6B (7.81%) -- all of which are also located in the waters northwest of Palawan. PNOC-EC also holds 19% interest in SC 43 located in Ragay Gulf in Bicol; 97% in SC 47 located offshore Mindoro province; 25% in SC 59 located in waters southwest of Palawan; and 10% in SC 38, 28% in SC 57, and 50% in SC 58 all located in waters northwest of Palawan. -- Claire-Ann Marie C. Feliciano


source: Businessworld

Reclamation row far from over

THE CONTEST for a multibillion-peso reclamation project in Pasay is far from over given an apparent division within the city government.

The city council on Wednesday passed a resolution recalling its approval of SM Land, Inc.’s P54.5-billion unsolicited proposal to reclaim 300 hectares of land. The city’s Public-Private Partnership Selection Committee (PPP-SC), however, declared the deal would push through.

"We are proceeding with the project," city legal officer Severo C. Madrona, Jr., who sits as PPP-SC vice-chairman, in a interview yesterday. "We have to ignore it (the resolution), but we will write them (the city council) to clarify each point."

SM Land said it could go to the courts given the city council’s move, which rival developer Ayala Land, Inc. welcomed.

"SM Land opines that there are legal remedies available and SM Land will not hesitate in pursuing such recourse if the council insists on this course of action," the company said in a statement.

Dave L. Rafael, the property developer’s senior vice-president, added: "We don’t want to delve on the motives behind why the city council is now belatedly withdrawing its support, but frankly, they were ill-advised."

City council members were not immediately available for comment.

Ayala Land corporate secretary Solomon M. Hermosura, for his part, said city council’s move was "in the right direction."

Mr. Madrona, however, said the "agreement is a perfected contract. We complied with all applicable laws, rules and regulations and it was ratified by the city council."

In Resolution 3059, Series of 2013, issued earlier this week however, the council recalled three prior decisions allowing the reclamation project to move forward. These were Resolution 3040, which allowed the PPP-SC to proceed with the opening of competing proposals; Resolution 3046, which allowed Mayor Antonio G. Calixto to sign the agreement with SM Land; and Resolution 3049, which ratified the award.

With no counterproposals having been submitted by a Nov. 4 deadline, the PPP-SC granted the contract to SM Land last Nov. 15.

This week’s Resolution 3059 was passed after hearings -- for the purpose of crafting new PPP rules -- where Ayala Land and S&P Construction Technology and Development Co. questioned the bidding process.

Ayala Land argued that a 2013 version of National Economic and Development Authority (NEDA) joint venture guidelines, which give challengers more time to prepare, should have been used instead of the 2008 set. S&P Construction, meanwhile, claimed the Build-Operate-Transfer law should have been applied and that bid documents lacked details.

In the Resolution 3059, the city council said "the issue raised by both Ayala Land and S&P Construction cast serious doubt on the legality of the proceedings made with respect to the ... reclamation and development project."

Mr. Madrona denied this, saying: "The 2013 version of the NEDA JV Guidelines is still being reviewed by the PPP Center."

"We don’t want to be the ‘guinea pig’ for these guidelines."

Asked to comment on the lack of project details, Mr. Madrona replied: "Those claims are not true. It was clearly stated there what the competitive challenger needs to do."

 
source:  Businessworld

Sunday, December 1, 2013

Exploration progresses in Mindoro oil prospect

THE GROUP handling Service Contract (SC) 53 located onshore Mindoro province aims to drill the second of two planned exploration wells in the first half of next year, according to a regulatory filing.

In its third-quarter financial report, The Philodrill Corp. -- which holds 22% stake in the project -- said the operator of SC 53, Pitkin Petroleum Plc., is already preparing for drilling the second well at the Progreso prospect.

“With regard to the planned drilling activity, Pitkin continued with the preparation for the drilling of Progreso-2 well which is programmed for the first half of 2014,” the report read.

Philodrill said that Pitkin -- which holds a 35% stake in SC 53 -- has progressed in securing approvals for the planned drilling activity.

“The operator has already achieved some success in securing approval of tribal communities and the National Commission for Indigenous People for its various activities on the block,” the company noted.

Last August, Basic Energy Corp. reported that the consortium of SC 53 was set to drill the Progreso-2 well, the second of two exploration facilities under the work program.

Basic Energy has a 3% interest in the SC. The other consortium members are Resource Management Associates Ltd. (35%); and Anglo Philippine Holdings Corp. (5%).

Basic Energy -- which is involved in various oil exploration activities -- also holds minority stakes in SC 47 located offshore Mindoro province and SC 41 in Sulu Sea.

The company recorded a P9.31-million net loss as of end-September compared to the P187.66-million net income in the same nine months last year. Revenues fell 91.3% to P20.23 million from P232.48 million, while costs and expenses dropped by 8.4% to P29.54 million from P32.25 million.

On the other hand, Philodrill -- which is engaged in oil, gas and mineral exploration and development -- holds interests in SC 6A, SC 6B, and SC 14 -- all located in waters northwest of Palawan; as well as SC 41 in Sulu Sea.

The firm’s profit dropped to P208.77 million in the nine months to September from P212.65 million the previous year. Revenues fell 6.46% to P499.26 million from P533.73 million, while costs expenses grew by 2.22% to P321.72 million from P314.74 million.

Shares of Philodrill closed at 3.7 centavos apiece on Friday last week, unchanged from Thursday, while those of Basic Energy added 3.90% to 24 centavos each from 23.1 centavos. -- Claire-Ann Marie C. Feliciano


source:  Businessworld

New PPPs lined up

BIDDING SCHEDULES for two more public-private partnership (PPP) projects are being finalized after National Economic and Development Authority (NEDA) approvals were secured by implementing agencies last month.

The Metropolitan Waterworks and Sewerage System (MWSS) plans to publish the invitation to prequalify and bid (ITPB) for the P24.4-billion Bulacan Bulk Water Supply Project -- the first water PPP -- in January, Administrator Gerardo A. I. Esquivel said.

"We already have a timeline but this is still indicative. Publishing of [the] invitation will be from Jan. 3 to 17 for the Bulacan Bulk Water Supply Project," Mr. Esquivel told BusinessWorld last Friday.

An indicative timeline prepared by MWSS sets the submission and opening of prequalification documents on Feb. 4, to be followed by a 20-day evaluation period. Bid submissions have been tentatively set for Aug. 29 and a notice of award could be issued between Oct. 10-14.

The first water PPP project to be rolled out by the Aquino government entails the provision of treated water to some 24 local government units via the development of new sources and infrastructure.

"The concession period is 30 years, from 2015 to 2045. It has three stages ... the first one covers six water districts to be delivered by 2016...," Mr. Esquivel said.

The first stage calls for the provision of 100 million liters of water per day (MLD) to the municipalities of Obando, Meycauayan, Marilao, Bocaue, Balagtas and San Jose del Monte, while the second involves a 375 MLD volume for Calumpit, Bulakan, Guiguinto, Sta. Maria, Malolos, Paombong, Plaridel, Pulilan and Hagonoy. The final stage covers 237 MLD for Angat, Baliwag, Bustos, Norzagaray, San Miguel, Don Remedios Trinidad, San Ildefonso, San Rafael and Pandi.

TRANSPORT TERMINALS
The Transportation department, meanwhile, is planning to publish this month the ITPB for the P7.7-billion Development of Transportation System at the Food Terminal Inc. (FTI) and Philippine Reclamation Authority (PRA) -- originally known as the Integrated Terminal System (ITS) project.

"The target is to start the bidding process ... this December," Transportation department spokesman Michael Arthur C. Sagcal said in a text message.

The PPP project involves the development of two facilities at the southern outskirts of Metro Manila: the South Luzon Express Way Terminal within the FTI Compound in Taguig, which will serve passengers traveling to and from Laguna and Batangas, and the Coastal Road Terminal inside the PRA property along the Manila-Cavite Expressway that will be for passengers traveling to and from Cavite.

Separate auctions will be staged for both.

The ITS project originally had three components -- two south stations and one north station. PPP Center Executive Director Cosette V. Canilao said the Transportation department "is still looking for the appropriate location" for the north facility. -- Claire-Ann Marie C. Feliciano and Lorenz Christoffer S. Marasigan

 
source:  Businessworld